In 1958, Duke Ellington (with the aid of Billy Strayhorn) wrote 22 songs for a Broadway musical entitled Saturday Laughter with lyricist Herb Martin. Unfortunately, the show set in South Africa and featuring an all-black cast was never produced on the big stage and the songs languished in obscurity for over 40 years, until now. Originally prepared for an April 2000 concert presented by the Duke Ellington Society at St. Peter¹s Church in Manhattan in which all 22 songs were arranged and performed 12 of them have now been recorded by an all-star lineup on Secret Ellington for True Life Entertainment.
For the project, veteran jazz producer Todd Barkan brought together a revolving ensemble featuring 20 of today¹s top jazz vocalists and instrumentalists to perform new arrangements of these 12 songs (on 14 tracks total two of the strongest melodies received two different treatments). The result is not only a historic event and a powerful tribute to Ellington, but also a truly enchanting disc.
The diverse and expressive vocalists are FREDDY COLE, JEFFERY SMITH, JUDI SILVANO, KAREN OBERLIN, and IAN SHAW. The stellar lineup of musicians on the disc includes: saxophonists JOE LOVANO, ERIC ALEXANDER, GROVER WASHINGTON, JR. and BOB KINDRED; flutist LOU MARINI; vibraphonist JOE LOCKE; pianists ARTURO O¹FARRILL and JAMES PEARSON; guitarist JOE BECK; bassists GEORGE MRAZ, CHIP JACKSON, and MICHAEL POPE; and drummers STEVE BERRIOS, MARK FLETCHER, and KEITH CARLOCK.
The compositions themselves only existed in poorly-recorded demo tapes and sketchy, often inaccurate, lead sheets (Ellington never orchestrated them for his orchestra), so the arrangements were written by participating musicians: seven by Beck, one by Shaw, two by Pearson, and four by O¹Farrill (who provided the arrangements for the 2000 concert). Ellington authority Luther Henderson also served as musical consultant.
The upbeat "You Are Beautiful" kicks off the disc with Shaw providing the rhapsodic lyrics and Eric Alexander crafting a lightning tenor sax solo. On "They Say," Grover Washington, Jr. (in what turned out to be his final recording session) gives a heart-breaking intro and accompaniment to Freddy Cole¹s soft delivery of the poignant words. "This Man" brings together the ethereal vibes of Joe Locke and some Stan Getz-inspired tenor saxophone from Bob Kindred for a breezy samba, underpinned by Joe Beck¹s intriguing chord work.
The touching ballad "Only Yesterday" then gets two minimalist treatments: the first with Shaw on vocals accompanied by Pearson¹s piano and Kindred¹s sax; the second, a rich duet between Joe Lovano and Beck on alto guitar.
Shaw delivers the life-affirming "I Like Singing" with Pearson¹s stride piano and a jaunty solo by Alexander. Lou Marini¹s alto flute introduces an appropriately mysterious "Full of Shadows" with vocals by Jeffery Smith. Beck propels the modern instrumental groove of "New Shoes" with Kindred, Locke, Michael Pope on bass, and vibrant drumming from Keith Carlock.
What follows next is an ingenious O¹Farrill arrangement of the song "I Am Lonely." Lovano supplies a cascading intro and his wife Judi Silvano intones a rubato prelude before singing the main theme over an inspired Ellingtonian chord progression. The band moves in and out of a subtle swing, Lovano explores the harmonic intricacies of the composition, and the song recaps its extended theme all in all, a masterful updating of an alluring Ellington work.
The opener "You Are Beautiful" is then reprised in a lyrical reading by Freddy Cole with O¹Farrill on piano. Kindred convincingly delivers the hard-swinging melody for the instrumental track "I Get Lonely for a Plaything" (although the title does hint at an intriguing lyric). The cabaret vocalist Karen Oberlin makes an appearance to sing "You Walk In My Dreams," perhaps the most "musical theater"-esque track on the disc.
Locke, Beck, and Kindred re-unite for their third instrumental, "Big White Mountain," driven by the irrepressible pulse of Michael Pope and drummer Keith Carlock. Finally, Jeffery Smith gives a touching performance of "My Home Lies Quiet" that brings to mind Ellington¹s devout "Come Sunday."
Herb Martin and playwright Henry Miller are currently reviving "Saturday Laughter" as a new play called "Renaissance Man," transporting the action from 1950s South Africa to 1920s Harlem. Although Ellington¹s original project never made it to Broadway, Secret Ellington finally brings these provocative compositions to light in the best way possible through inventive new arrangements performed by a superior group of top vocalists and instrumentalists. And with several compositions absent from this collection, Barkan and True Life Entertainment have room to continue this significant project in the future.
Fri Mar 8 2002 (7:35:00 PM)